Question 148 – Is it morally licit to donate your organs?

Interview Organization: The Confraternity of Our Lady of Fatima
Interviewer Name: Christopher P. Wendt
Date: January 13, 2023
There is no definitive Church teaching on organ donation. "Brain death" is an artificial concept, and cases exist where so-called brain-dead individuals regain life, complicating the issue. Organ donation raises moral concerns, as it may violate the commandment against killing. Exceptions exist for martyrs acting out of charity, but direct killing for organ removal is immoral.
If you like what we do and want to regularly support our mission to build the Reign of Mary and/or assist the episcopal ministry of Bishop Athanasius Schneider, please consider becoming a Servant of Mary.

Transcripts:

There is no definitive teaching of the Church, it does not exist. What does organ donation mean? Does it mean you are dead? If the body is dead, it cannot be a living organism.

This so-called brain death is an artificial definition of a non-functioning brain, and there are cases where these so-called brain-dead people begin to wake up and start to live. With this, there is a lot of abuse and manipulation with organ donations. Brain-dead people still have a soul in their bodies, and it is not separated.

This would be a very confusing situation, and the Church has not yet declared it. However, from common sense and experience, we know that this issue is very confusing.

We cannot simply say, "I will donate my organs," because it depends on which organs you can donate. For example, if you can donate your kidneys but cannot donate your other life-supporting organs, you will still need them to live. So, in this case, we cannot commit any form of suicide.

We have to keep the law of God. You cannot consent to such things that entertain the possibility of killing yourself. When you take out your organs, this is against the commandment of God: "Thou shalt not kill."

There are exceptions, however, in the case of the martyrs, especially when they were taking care of the sick and contracted the disease. This is a different case because it involves an act of charity. The direct killing of a person and taking out his organs is immoral.