Q377 – Is It Too Early To Tell the Direction of Pope Leo Based on the Current Appointments He Has Made?

Interview Organization: Confraternity of Our Lady of Fatima
Interviewer Name: Christopher P. Wendt
Date: July 13, 2025
The Pope’s key duty is appointing faithful, trustworthy, deeply Catholic men as bishops and cardinals. Neglecting this invites harm, allowing wolves into the flock. Appointing those known for error or worldliness is a grave matter. The Pope must act carefully, consulting reliable advisors, as God will hold him accountable.
If you like what we do and want to regularly support our mission to build the Reign of Mary and/or assist the episcopal ministry of Bishop Athanasius Schneider, please consider becoming a Servant of Mary.

Yes, I am convinced and in my opinion, this is true that one of the main tasks of the Pope, as the successor of Peter, is to provide the Church with worthy men, men who are completely trustworthy in their fidelity to the integrity of the Catholic faith, and men of God, formed with a deep Catholic, and apostolic spirit.

Otherwise, if he neglects attention and care in the selection of candidates, it is as if he is allowing wolves to enter the flock, who will cause great harm to the sheep. And the Pope is the chief pastor. By appointing bishops who promote confusion, ambiguity, or even known errors, who are known before their appointment to support a liberal or worldly agenda, he endangers the flock.

To appoint such candidates despite prior knowledge of their positions, or to be careless in selecting men without regard for the integrity of doctrine and personal piety, is a grave matter. Of course, a bishop must also be prudent and possess sound judgment. But these characteristics, fidelity, piety, orthodoxy, are so essential that the Pope cannot simply rely on his collaborators. He must take time and also consult with other trustworthy persons in the selection of episcopal candidates.

And this applies also, of course, to the cardinalate. As the chief pastor of the entire flock, the Pope, by appointing dubious, ambiguous, or openly heterodox candidates, is effectively opening the door for wolves to enter the fold.

This is a serious responsibility. And I believe that God will ask each Pope, personally, to give an account for his appointments. And that is no small matter.

Question/ Title